Broken Trust Documentary Analysis
The brave women and men featured in this documentary have found the courage to speak out against abuse on all fronts and are given a voice through "Broken Trust". Broken Trust examines how and why abuse occurs as well as what has to be done to stop it through interviews with Olympic and national-level athletes, coaches, and specialists.
This documentary offers viewers a direct insight into the hidden world of sexual and emotional abuse suffered by athletes. Broken Trust demonstrates how athletes are shamed and marginalized for speaking up, how parents are coerced into remaining silent when predators pose as well-intentioned coaches, and how athletes who dared to question the existing quo were refused critical financial support.
This story is constructed with careful editing, camera angles, and sound techniques that all complement the subject.
Mise-en-scene
- Jessica Armstrong, a Former elite gymnast is introduced in a light blue shirt with a black suit on top. This can represent freedom, intuition, inspiration, and sensitivity. The sensitivity of this subject can not only be seen through the colors but their emotions throughout the first episode of the documentary.
- When Nancy Hogshead is introduced; she is seated in a velvet chair wearing a colorful patterned scarf that adds more weight to the speaker and their words. She is presented as elegant and wise due to her posture, her confident voice, and the hues of purple in her clothing.
- A clip of the new subject is displayed whenever the documentary switches to a new subtopic; this is done by playing a tape of a senator speaking, a news anchor reporting, or another person reporting about abuse in sports.
- In order to emphasize Katelyn Ohashi's experience and youngness, she is presented in a black t-shirt with a gym background. She also has no makeup or hair done which can express her true age and honesty to the audience.
- John Hoberman, a sports historian, is wearing a light beige shirt, and the pleasant hues of the frame and the absence of harsh light suggest that he is not a survivor but rather a character who will further the plot.
- During the interview, the subject is the only thing the camera is focused on; everything else looks out of focus.
- There are more close-ups of the women than the men being interviewed.
- Setting the mood with a dramatic sound.
- The music was turned down throughout the interviews.
- The music at the beginning was a faster pace compared to the music throughout the rest of the interview. This allowed the audience to connect the music to what they are talking about in their past, it showed how happy they were to be playing the sport they did.
- Once they started talking about the sexual abuse subject the music became ominous.
- When the professor speaks, the music gets a little louder and more suspenseful as he discusses the bond between a male coach and an athlete.
- The interviewees continued by discussing how abuse was made public in these sporting communities, and at this point, the music changed the mood and became more suspenseful.
- When the victims are speaking about how they survived and what they did to move past the abuse, the music gradually gets louder to make a bigger impression.
- As the music plays in the background and progressively gets louder, Katelyn Ohashi's voice has a faint echo to it.
- Throughout the end of the episode, the music was getting soothing
- Short clips of the subject as a child performing their sport are intercut with the interviewer and the subject being interviewed. This method was frequently employed to relate the speaker to their sport and depict the setting in which the abuse was occurring.
- Included a photograph of a newspaper story about Jessica Armstrong when she was younger and her career was just getting started. The image slowly zooms into the newspaper to give the audience a feeling of intimacy.
- News clips are edited into the interview to provide evidence and more background information
- At the end of the documentary, a black screen is used as a transition. During this transition, Katelyn Ohashi begins talking about change and the influence that athletes have.
- A close-up shot of Katelyn Ohashi faded in.
- The documentary begins by showcasing four different athletes from different sports before introducing more as it progresses (gymnastics, swimming, ice skating, sprint canoe racer, speed ice skating). This diversity is meant to demonstrate to the audience that both genders can become victims of abuse in all sports.
- The victims discuss their passion for their sport, how they got started at a young age, and what drove them. The spectators can identify with these athletes and experience the sport from their perspective.
- To demonstrate how these sports are supposed to be managed and how they are actually being collected, the story switches to coaches and the dynamics inside that sport.
- These contradictory videos illustrate the bigger issue—that many victim athletes go unnoticed while the coaches enjoy the backing of the community.
- People who have personally experienced the abuse that is being committed are included; they provide a different viewpoint on the matter.
- The speech Katelyn Ohashi gave at the end, in which she addressed both the perpetrators of abuse in the world of athletics and the people who are unaware of this kind of issue, allows the audience to really take into consideration the issue at hand.
“Broken Trust is an honest depiction of survivors’ experiences and illuminates how sexual violence takes place within sports. This film begins necessary conversations on how we can prevent sexual violence in sports.”
— David Lee | Director of Prevention, RALIANCE
Photo Credit: https://mediaed.uscreen.io/programs/broken-trust
.jpeg)
Comments
Post a Comment